AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |
Back to Blog
The witness demo4/27/2023 ![]() The Jury Room Demonstration Violated Important Rights In this case the issue of how much pressure was necessary to fire the gun was the topic of expert testimony, as most people do not handle guns on a regular basis and therefore expert opinion was necessary. Conversely, demonstrations that entail more than the application of everyday perceptions and common sense are prohibited. Jurors may conduct a jury room crime reenactment or demonstration provided it involves no more than the jurors application of everyday experiences and common sense regarding the evidence, People v. The Law On Jury Room Demonstrations:Īs a general rule, a jury verdict may not be impeached by proof of the tenor of its deliberations, but it may be upon a showing of improper influence, which includes even well intentioned jury conduct that tends to put the jury in possession of evidence not introduced at trial. The seemingly simple out-of-court demonstration violated several important constitutional rights including, the Sixth Amendment right to confrontation, the right to be present at every stage of the proceeding, the right to cross-examine witnesses, and the rule against unsworn witnesses and testimony contributing to a conviction. Liang was charged with manslaughter in the second degree and convicted after a trial by jury. ![]() Akai Gurley on the floor below, piercing his heart and killing him. The sound of a slamming door startled him and his gun went off the bullet ricocheted off a wall and hit Mr. Officer Liang had his gun drawn, but did not have his finger on the trigger. In 2014 Officer Peter Liang was on a vertical patrol in the dark stairwell of a high-rise building in New York City. This unsupervised deliberation room experiment with Liangs gun took place outside of the courtroom, outside of the view of the judge, the attorneys, and the defendant. Juror number nine told the press that he had extensive experience with guns and that it wasnt hard for him to pull the trigger at all. Although the gun was not loaded for the jury room demonstration, the jury ultimately concluded from this test how much pressure on the trigger was necessary to fire the gun. Juror number nine stated that a jury room demonstration had taken place where each juror took a turn with the gun to determine how much pressure was necessary to pull the trigger. The trial court should conduct a hearing prior to sentencing to determine whether the jury room demonstration was illegally conducted and whether one or more of the jurors became an unauthorized expert witness. One of the jurors spoke out and revealed some interesting and problematic details about the deliberations and the jury room demonstration that took place using Liangs gun. ![]() Last week, a jury convicted Officer Peter Liang of manslaughter in the second degree. ![]() Recklessness: The Case Of Officer Peter Liang See also: Mens Rea And The Case Of Innocent Conduct vs. JURY ROOM DEMONSTRATIONS: THE CASE OF OFFICER PETER LIANG AND THE JUROR THAT BECAME AN EXPERT WITNESS.
0 Comments
Read More
Leave a Reply. |